LucidLink vs Frame.io vs iconik vs Shade (2026): What Each Does, What They Cost and Which to Choose
10 min
red
LucidLink, Frame.io and iconik do three different jobs. LucidLink is the cloud drive editors work from, Frame.io handles client review and approval, and iconik is media asset management. Many teams run two or all three together, so choose by your biggest problem: slow remote editing, client sign-off or a library nobody can search. Shade (our product) is the fourth option here, a single product that does all three jobs: cloud drive, review and approval, and AI search and asset management.
At enterprise scale they converge: all four put SSO on quote-only plans, and you need an Enterprise contract above 25 members on LucidLink and above 15 on Frame.io and Shade.
We checked every price and feature on the vendor's own site on November 11, 2026. Prices exclude sales tax, and the team-size figures are examples, not quotes.
What each tool does
LucidLink streams files from cloud object storage so they behave like a local drive. Editors open large media on demand instead of syncing it first. There is no review or search layer. See our LucidLink review and LucidLink alternatives.
Frame.io, owned by Adobe, is built for review and approval: frame-accurate comments, annotations, version stacks, client share links and Camera to Cloud for ingest from set. Since April 2026 it also offers Frame.io Drive, a desktop app that mounts a limited amount of storage. Our Frame.io review goes deeper.
iconik, from Backlight, is a cloud media asset management (MAM) platform. It indexes media wherever it lives, in its own storage or yours (including on-prem through a storage gateway), and adds metadata, search, review and workflow automation. Read our iconik review and iconik alternatives.
Shade is a cloud NAS for video teams. Editors mount it as a drive and cut from it, clients review the same files with frame-accurate comments, and every upload is indexed for AI search by spoken words, faces and scene content. One seat covers the drive, review and approval and search.
How do teams combine them?
Usually as layers, not alternatives.
LucidLink under iconik. LucidLink documents using a filespace as an iconik storage location, so iconik indexes and transcodes what editors already work on. iconik describes the integration the same way: LucidLink appears as a standard volume, and iconik watches it for new content.
LucidLink with Frame.io. LucidLink Connect brings Frame.io footage, and other cloud sources such as S3 or Dropbox, into a filespace. Files stream from where they are stored, so footage uploaded through Frame.io, including Camera to Cloud, can be edited without a download. Connect is an Enterprise add-on.
iconik and Frame.io overlap. iconik has built-in review and approval and calls it comparable to Frame.io. Its integration list has no native Frame.io connector, so teams pick one review tool or run both.
Running the full stack means three vendors to pay, three seat counts to keep in step and three admin consoles. That overhead is the case for an all-in-one such as Shade, covered below; our LucidLink alternatives and Frame.io alternatives lists cover other options.
Side-by-side comparison
LucidLink | Frame.io | iconik | Shade | |
Job | Cloud drive for editing | Review and approval | Media asset management | All three: cloud drive, review, AI search and asset management |
Plans and list price | Starter $7; Business $27 per member per month annually ($32 monthly); Enterprise quoted | Free; Pro $15, Team $25 per member per month ($13, $22 annually); Enterprise quoted | Starter: Power $120, Standard $65, Browse $9, Collaborator $0 per user per month; others custom | Growth $29.75 per seat per month annually ($35 monthly); Enterprise custom |
Storage included | 100 GB (Starter) or 400 GB (Business) per member, pooled | Pro 2 TB, Team 3 TB, plus 2 TB per added member | Bring your own, or use iconik's on usage credits ($1 each) | 500 GB active per seat (Growth), 1 TB (Enterprise), pooled; add-ons priced on request |
Egress | Included in plans | Not listed as a separate charge | Usage-based on Starter; Professional includes proxy storage, transfers and egress | No separate egress charge |
Member limits | Starter 10; Business 25; Enterprise unlimited | Pro 5; Team 15; Enterprise custom | No stated cap | Growth 15 seats (150 guests); Enterprise unlimited seats |
Review | No | Yes, the category benchmark | Yes; synchronized review capped at 2 users on Starter, 10 on Professional | Yes: timestamped and range comments, annotations, version stacking, guest access |
Search and metadata | Folder based | Custom metadata, collections, transcription, captions; AI search (visual search in beta) | Deep metadata, AI enrichment, automation; facial recognition from Professional | AI search by spoken words, faces and scenes; custom and automated metadata |
NLE and app integrations | Any app that opens files from a local drive: Premiere Pro, Resolve, Avid, Final Cut Pro | Premiere Pro, Final Cut Pro, Lightroom; Camera to Cloud hardware and software | Adobe Creative Cloud panel, Final Cut Pro, 65+ listed integrations | Premiere Pro panel; Resolve, Avid and Final Cut Pro through the drive |
Edit from the cloud | Yes, its core job | Frame.io Drive mounts 250 GB (Pro), 500 GB (Team), 2 TB (Enterprise) | Through connected storage such as LucidLink | Yes: mounted drive on macOS, Windows and Linux; all active storage editable |
Bring your own storage | Enterprise only (S3) | Storage Connect (your AWS S3 bucket), Enterprise Prime only | Yes, on every plan | Enterprise only: Amazon S3, Google Cloud Storage, Backblaze or Wasabi |
Extra LucidLink storage is $7 (Starter) or $8 (Business) per 100 GB a month. Frame.io's visual search covers Team and Enterprise only.
Pricing at 10, 25 and 50 people
These examples use list prices with every person on a paid seat. Real teams often have free reviewers and guests, and iconik's bill also depends on who logs in each month and how much storage, egress, AI and automation they use.
Team size (example) | LucidLink | Frame.io | iconik Starter (example role mix) | Shade |
10 people | Business: $270 a month annually ($320 monthly), 4 TB included | Team: $220 annually ($250 monthly); 3 TB plus 2 TB for each of 9 added members | $480 (2 Power, 3 Standard, 5 Browse), plus usage | Growth: $297.50 annually ($350 monthly); 500 GB per seat, 5 TB pooled |
25 people | Business: $675 annually ($800 monthly), 10 TB included; the member cap | Above the 15-member Team cap: Enterprise, quote only | $1,228 (5 Power, 8 Standard, 12 Browse), plus usage | Above the 15-seat Growth cap: Enterprise, quote only, 1 TB per seat |
50 people | Above the 25-member Business cap: Enterprise, quote only | Enterprise, quote only | $2,400 (10 Power, 15 Standard, 25 Browse), plus usage; SSO needs Professional (custom) | Enterprise, quote only, 1 TB per seat |
Seat caps shape these bills more than list prices do. Frame.io needs Enterprise above 15 members and LucidLink above 25, and neither publishes Enterprise pricing. Shade Growth also stops at 15 seats, so at 25 and 50 people Shade is an Enterprise quote too.
iconik works the other way. It has no stated cap, and the total swings with your role mix: if most of your 50 people are reviewers on Browse ($9) or free Collaborator seats, the bill is far lower. If most are Standard or Power users, it is far higher.
Ten people is where the comparison is cleanest. The three-tool stack in this example comes to about $970 a month on annual billing before iconik usage ($270 plus $220 plus $480). Shade Growth is $297.50 for the same team before storage add-ons. The stack holds more total storage, but most of it is Frame.io review storage rather than a drive editors cut from. Shade does not publish its add-on storage price, so ask for a quote before comparing totals. On billing terms, annual plans save 15% on LucidLink ($27 against $32) and 12% on Frame.io Team ($22 against $25).
For more on what MAM costs, see our MAM pricing guide.
Security and admin controls
Control | LucidLink | Frame.io | iconik | Shade |
Certifications | SOC 2 (Type I and II), ISO 27001, TPN Blue, GDPR | SOC 2 Type 2, ISO 27001 (through Adobe's certification), TPN Gold Shield | SOC 2 Type II; ISO 27001 and TPN not named | SOC 2 Type II, ISO 27001 and TPN certified; HIPAA and GDPR compliant |
SSO | Enterprise only, SAML 2.0 | Enterprise only, SAML2-based | SAML on Professional and Enterprise, not Starter | Enterprise only, SSO/SAML |
SCIM | Yes, once SSO is set up, so Enterprise | Not named; provisioning runs through Adobe's Admin Console, whose Entra ID sync uses SCIM | Not supported | Enterprise |
Audit logging | File system audit trail on Enterprise; Splunk, Elastic and CloudWatch integrations | Account audit logs through its API; plan not stated | Basic logs on Starter and Professional; full trail and SIEM streaming via Shield on Enterprise | Enterprise |
Encryption | Zero-knowledge; AES-256 with GCM; per-file keys | AES-256 server-side on Amazon S3; TLS in transit | End-to-end encryption on every plan | All files encrypted in transit and at rest |
Content protection | Guest link expiry on Business and up | Static watermark from Pro; session, forensic watermarking and DRM on Enterprise packages | Dynamic watermarking from Professional; DRM and forensic watermarking as add-ons | Link passwords, expiry, view limits and watermarks; session watermarks on Enterprise |
On Frame.io, session-based watermarking is a paid add-on to the Enterprise Select package, and forensic watermarking and DRM are exclusive to Enterprise Prime.
All four put SSO and their strongest admin controls on quote-only plans, so expect an Enterprise conversation whichever you choose. Check two things early: how Frame.io's directory sync through Adobe's Admin Console works with your identity provider, and which TPN level your clients require.
Which should you choose?
Your situation | Pick | Why |
Remote editors waiting on downloads of large media | LucidLink | Built for exactly this; storage and egress are included in plans |
Agencies and studios that need client sign-off in Adobe tools | Frame.io | Deepest Premiere Pro and After Effects integration, Camera to Cloud, polished shares |
Large library on many storage systems, with a media manager | iconik | Catalogs in place; deep metadata and automation |
Want storage, review and search in one tool | Shade | One seat count, one admin console and one bill instead of three |
Need SCIM provisioning | LucidLink Enterprise or Shade Enterprise; check Frame.io Enterprise | Both document SCIM; Frame.io syncs users through Adobe's Admin Console; iconik has no SCIM |
Need TPN for studio work | Frame.io, LucidLink or Shade | Frame.io lists TPN+ Gold Shield on every plan, LucidLink TPN Blue; Shade is TPN certified |
Need audit logs in your SIEM | iconik Enterprise or LucidLink Enterprise | iconik Shield streams through AWS SQS or Google Cloud Pub/Sub; LucidLink lists Splunk, Elastic, CloudWatch |
50 or more people | Any of the four | LucidLink, Frame.io and Shade need Enterprise quotes; iconik Starter has no stated cap |
Replacing the stack with Shade
Shade's argument is consolidation: the drive, review links and search index all work from the same files, so nobody exports a cut to re-upload it or keeps a second catalog. For admins it means one seat count, one console and one identity setup, where the three-tool stack splits users across LucidLink, Adobe's Admin Console and iconik, which has no SCIM.
At 25 or 50 people the plan to price is Shade Enterprise: custom pricing, unlimited seats, 1 TB of active storage per seat, SSO/SAML, SCIM and audit logging, an enterprise SLA and data migration. Bring your own storage is Enterprise only (Amazon S3, Google Cloud Storage, Backblaze or Wasabi). Teams of up to 15 can start on Growth at $29.75 per seat per month billed annually ($35 month to month), with 500 GB of active storage per seat.
Where the specialists still beat it:
Camera to Cloud. Frame.io has it. Shade does not.
Review alone, on Adobe. If you are standardized on Adobe and mainly need client review, Frame.io Team costs less at $22 per member per month billed annually, for up to 15 members.
Media spread across systems you want to keep. iconik catalogs them in place, and its metadata schemas and automation go deeper than Shade's.
Two plan limits matter too. Growth stops at 15 seats (LucidLink Business allows 25), and add-on storage is priced on request, so get a quote if your library will outgrow what is included.
For the details, see Shade vs LucidLink, Shade vs Frame.io and Shade vs iconik. Our two-way posts cover the pairs: LucidLink vs iconik, iconik vs Frame.io and LucidLink vs Frame.io.
Frequently asked questions
Are LucidLink, Frame.io and iconik competitors?
Not head to head. Each began in a different layer of the media stack, and plenty of teams pay for two or all three. The overlap is growing at the edges, though: Frame.io now mounts a small drive, and iconik ships its own review tools.
Do I need all three?
Only if you have all three problems. Common pairs are LucidLink plus Frame.io (about $490 a month for 10 people on annual billing, with no catalog) and iconik with its built-in review. Shade covers all three jobs in one tool: Growth for up to 15 seats, Enterprise with no seat cap.
Can iconik replace Frame.io?
For client review in the browser, it may be enough, though Starter limits synchronized review to 2 users. Frame.io keeps the edge in Premiere Pro, After Effects and Camera to Cloud, so if your editors live in Adobe tools, run one real project through both.
Is Frame.io Drive a replacement for LucidLink?
Not for a whole team's working media. Frame.io Drive, launched in April 2026, mounts 250 GB on Pro, 500 GB on Team and 2 TB on Enterprise, and Frame.io sells mounted storage add-ons. LucidLink Business includes 400 GB per member, pooled and all on the drive, so 10 members edit from 4 TB.
Does LucidLink work with Frame.io and iconik?
Yes, with both. iconik can use a LucidLink filespace as a storage location and watch it for new media. Frame.io footage reaches a filespace through LucidLink Connect, which needs a LucidLink Enterprise plan.
How much do LucidLink, Frame.io and iconik cost together for 10 people?
About $970 a month at list price on annual billing, before iconik usage, with the example role mix above. On monthly billing it is about $1,050 ($320 for LucidLink, $250 for Frame.io and $480 for iconik). Shade Growth for the same 10 people is $297.50 a month billed annually, or $350 month to month, before storage add-ons.